In 1993 Canadian citizens received a rude awakening.
Our ‘peace-keepers’, members of the Canadian Airborne Regiment, tortured and killed a Somolian teen-ager. The boy was 16.
The government and the military brass chose to ignore the central decay of a department that had been unable to detect the bad characters and properly train the good. Instead the DND just got rid of the Airborne. But the leadership did start to recognize the strain of involving Canadian soldiers in so many missions, if only because with the scandals the PR value of peace-keeping was starting to erode.*
And now the UK and the US wrestle with the dogs of war.
This Asia Time article mocks how the average western citizen perceives war.
What caught my attention is that this piece is directed at the viewer, we - the computer chair/couch potato observers.
Don’t you remember the stark images in Life magazine of US soldiers torturing suspected communists during the Vietnam War? Have you forgotten about the My Lai massacre? Did you think the Disasters of War, as depicted by Spanish artist Francisco de Goya in 1810-11 (click here ) were things that only other countries perpetrated, in other times?
Did you think American wars are more civilized, more humane? Well, of course you did. Your president and your media, after the nonsense about weapons of mass destruction had been swept under the carpet, sold you this war as ridding the world of the brutal, bloodthirsty tyrant Saddam Hussein; as bringing the forces of humanity, civilization and enlightenment to a people living in darkness. And you believed that war could achieve this. Now, shocked, you are seeing images that show that the brutal, bloodthirsty tyrant’s boot fits some American feet as well. Sorry, but war is dehumanizing.
Your president thunders that prisoner abuse “is not the American way”. Maybe he really thinks so - he never saw service in Vietnam, or any other war, after all. Maybe his advisers just didn’t tell him what really goes on in war. But to all but the simple-minded and the rose-bespectacled, this is not only the American way of war, it is the way of all sides in all wars.
Yes. We forget if we know at all. We think we need life sanitized for us.
“Lest we forget” is a grand slogan if we are the ones that don’t have to do the awful remembering.
The underlings who will be punished are soldiers who were dragged along by the dogs of war. If you are shocked and appalled by what they did, it is those who let the dogs out who should be investigated. They have only one question to answer, and it is not “Did you order the maltreatment of Iraqi prisoners?” The question is, “Is this a just, necessary war?” If it is a just war, you may swallow your horror, because this is how wars are waged.
Sometimes war is unavoidable. Just don’t be naive about it. Sorry to say, the grim reality is a whole lot worse than what you have recently seen on the “stupid box”.
*The Lion The Fox & The Eagle - Carol Off. page 23
Published 4 years, 7 months ago
You are currently browsing the Bene Diction Blogs On weblog archives.
For blog design, Wordpress or MovableType coding or blog consulting, see cre8d design.
Excellent Bene.
Good post.
Just a note on the Airborne travesty. I saw a report one time that talked about disasters like this. It talked about how peace keeping is so much different than war yet we send over warriors over to do peacekeeping. It talked about the ruthlessness that war takes while peacekeeping (and occupation) is something very different.
The British say it takes a year to turn a group of soldiers into peacekeepers and a year to turn them back to soldiers again.
I wonder if the problem lies much more with political masters who don’t want to pay for the training and also with a military culture that I wonder likes to show off the baddest and meanest.
Nice post, someone has to say this stuff. My friend and I were discussing the very same topic online the other day, and pointing out that all the “photographic evidence” is just further propaganda for the sensation-seeking media to stir up the masses with. Be it true or not, it is for the proper channels to sort out, and it is time for us in the UK and US to wake up and face the realities of living in belligerent nations …
do you really think the uk and us will ever learn?