There was a murder on a bus in Canada Wednesday night, rare in it’s brutality, but not rare in that ordinary people are heroes. In split seconds of shock and horror people caught up in the unthinkable do what they need to do. The bus driver’s training kicked in, lives may have been saved. A mother at the back of the bus threw her child to another passenger who got the child out safely. The mother also got out safely. The murderer was locked inside, a stopping truck driver lent passengers some tools and a couple of men went in to see if they could save Tim McLean.
Some people who have not experienced violence won’t see the passenger and bus driver as heroes. Would have, could have, should have are common human themes.
What would I have done? is an intuitive response as our minds and emotions grapple with danger and death. It’s been my experience that what I’d like to do, what I want to do might not square up with that I would do, and I remain amazed at the courage and instincts I’ve seen in people who are caught in life threatening situations.
22 year old Tim McLean didn’t make it home. He travelling to Winnipeg after working the carnival circuit. He had a long trip. The bus left Edmonton just after midnight, and it would normally be a 20 hour 1300 kilometer ride to Winnipeg.
What appalls me is what the McLean family is experiencing. Their son’s murder occurred early Thursday morning and no police notified the family. His sister found out from a reporter Thursday night. It’s being reported seasoned officers who attended the crime scene were shocked. I get that. Human to human violence is not something we are able to scrub from our minds. Police officers are assigned tasks, and one of the tasks is notification of next of kin. The RCMP have enough personnel, what it appears they lacked is internal departmental communication. It isn’t the first time, it won’t be the last.
What I don’t get is why a reporter winds up being the one to tell a family member.
That happened to me once, and I’ve never gotten over it. Because of jurisdictional and territorial jostling between two police departments I was given false information by police about family notification. I believed the police and I will live with that broken trust the rest of my life. So will they. A mother lives with the emptiness of hearing a detached voice on her car radio saying her son’s body had been found.
I don’t know how to say this any clearer than this.
No reporter should ever be in the position they break the news of a death in a family. It is not the responsibility of media to tell anyone privately their child or sibling is dead. In the death of Tim McLean it was not the responsibility of the bus company to tell a family their son had been murdered.
On a lazy summer night on the Canadian prairies a vicious murder occurred, and it was reported around the world.
It was the responsibility of the RCMP.
Pending notification of next of kin are not empty words.
A reporter was at the family home last night when the RCMP finally arrived to speak to them. He’ll live with being the ‘news breaker’ the rest of his life. In the insanity of senselessness, the deep wells of shock and grief, the mistrust between jurisdictions and media and the banality of the 24/7 news cycle, our ability to use technology to instantly communicate; it is possible the reporter knew police had not talked to Tim McLean’s family and went to the family home anyway. He’ll have to live with his words.
A lot will be misreported, Transport Canada and the US bus company will go into overdrive and over-react. What matters in the short term is that passengers and the driver are given solid trauma counselling, police and first responders who attended are thoroughly de-briefed, and the McLean family is shown respect and given dignity by all the peripheral officials who carry out their tasks, and that this family is supported and held up by their community. Let their anger be heard so other families are less likely to experience failures of communication by those tasked by us to do so.
Earlier Friday, McLean’s family said they are angry at how long it took the RCMP to inform them that McLean was the victim.
CTV’s Murray Oliver visited the family’s house in Winnipeg Friday and spoke to McLean’s sister.
“She told us that in fact they didn’t know that Tim was the victim in this crime until last night when a journalist came to their house and knocked on the door,” said Oliver.
“Obviously they’re wondering why the RCMP did not come and inform the family for such a long time.”
He said the family had been following the story when the news first broke early Thursday.
“Then, to get the knock on the door, and to find out that it’s your son, it’s your brother — I can’t imagine how it must have been for them and that shock is written on their faces,” said Oliver.
He said the family was also angry with the media.
“Tim’s sister told us the family feels they really can’t say a word — not even to speak about Tim’s life — until they can assemble the family together and they can come up with a joint statement,” he said.
40 year old Vince Weiguang Li of Edmonton has been charged with second degree murder. He appeared in a Portage la Prairie court today; no lawyer, no family, no words.
My deepest sympathy goes out to Tim McLean’s family, friends and fellow travellers.
Published 5 months, 1 week ago
You are currently browsing the Bene Diction Blogs On weblog archives.
For blog design, Wordpress or MovableType coding or blog consulting, see cre8d design.
Nicely put, Bene.
RCMP officers came to our house years ago saying a family member had been arrested. Wasn’t true. It turns out they got names mixed up. That created a fuss, as you can imagine.
Well said - the driver and the passenger made exactly the right choices under the circumstances.
A lot of people survived because of their actions.
After reading some of the mindless posts on the CBC.ca website it is refreshing to read something well thought, reasonable and fair. This was the post that nearly drove me round the bend - horrible, incendiary and shocking:
“The family heard the news about thier son from a reporter? What kind of a lowlife scribe would not check with the RCMP first? A news scoop. This inconsiderate dog should be fired and pubicly tarred and feathered. A new low in decency and journalism. I have more to say about this pig, but not today.”
I ask - how can anyone write and post such garbage. You restore my faith in reason.
Kindly
Lance
http://www.stageleft.info/2008/08/01/damn-that-doesnt-sound-muslim/
They’ve collected a pretty good list of bloggers ,blaming, reacting and getting exercise jumping to conclusions.
I agree. Well said. Further, I have a father who had $6,000 stolen from him. He is a stroke victim, and is half-paralysed. After threats to the thief, we recovered the money. I will never forget the RCMP’s lack of response, lack of action, and ill-advice. Never. The RCMP stinks, and are a useless organization. They should not have taken this murderer in alive. Sharpshooters should have been called in to take him out. That way the family would be spared the misery of an on-going case, and this animal living off the penal system with three squares and a cot.
It is still completely beyond me why it did not occur to the remaining 35 passengers on the bus as well as to the driver to overpower Vince at the time that the first blow was dealt when Tim was apparently still alive, rather than leave Tim to the mercy of his vicious assailant.
Secondly, the response by Greyhound that they are unable to improve passenger safety aboard their buses is absolute baloney. Greyhound should adopt safety measures currently in place in Israel and being applied by the local bus line, Egged, which have saved many lives in the country, every bag being scrupulously checked before a passenger is allowed carry on luggage to board a bus.
Freddie, dark, cramped bus in the middle of the night, sleepy travellers. Could have, would have, should have. Our minds attempt to rationalize and organize, sort, solve.
If you have the coroners report, and a forensic timeline we’d like to see it.
You might enjoy Schneier on Security.
I am sorry for anyone who suffers loss such as this, I am angry for the family that no one seems to raise the question of how the attacker was permitted to board the Bus with these weapons in the first place?
In the states you go through extreme security once I was stopped and made to dispose of a “Plastic Knife that was included in a plastic utensil set I had gotten with the lunch I’d purchased before that long bus ride, and before even boarding the Greyhound Bus. And this man is allowed to board with a large hunting knife & scissors? I don’t get it.
and for these individuals that call themselves a church? Protesting someone’s funeral? I mean c’mon! what kind of a cold hearted individual does that? why would anyone cause futher pain to our fellow humans who are already suffering enough pain from such a tradgedy?
I’m sorry they should all be jailed for harrassment and disturbing the peace. Religion is a very personal thing and they should keep their’s to themselves and leave these poor people alone. They already suffer enough, in my opinion these individuals are not much different than the man who commited this crime.
Most of all I wish the family to somehow find peace perhaps find it in their hearts to share in some of my own beliefs and know that love never dies and that this beautiful young man has not gone away but is around them everyday. May you find peace until one day you’ll all be together again. Blessings …