Damned if he does or doesn’t; Stephen Harper at Romeo LeBlanc’s funeral mass

Stephen Harper was raised mainstream protestant and about 2 decades ago decided to join the Christian and Missionary Alliance Church. To his credit, like PMs before him he has not made a public issue of his denominational choices.

As a leader of The Canadian Alliance Party, The Conservative Party and as Prime Minister of Canada, he has been to his share of funerals in those leadership capacities.

He is also surrounded by staff versed in protocol who would be very aware he is insulting Roman Catholics by receiving the eucharist at a mass he is required to attend. I think he knew that. And I’ve no doubt the Archbishop of Moncton was aware the Prime Minister of Canada is not a Roman Catholic. Would it not be the responsibility of Roman Catholic leadership to tell none Catholics attending a state funeral the difference between receiving a blessing and the Eucharist?

I like Dr. John Stackhouse’s take on this kerfuffle at Holy Post, Harper accused of taking communion, Harper accused of pocketing the wafer. Damned if he does, damned if he doesn’t; should have, could have  just…

In the vast majority of protestant churches (including the CM&A) the concept of communion is different than in the Roman Catholic Church. The priest who gave the PM the Eucharist would be welcome to partake.

This was a state funeral, it is the responsibility of the Catholic leadership be clear to guests, for a protestant cannot come to the table in a Roman Catholic church.
Harper as Prime Minister is surrounded by security in a large crowd and like the disabled, the priest brings communion to him.

Third, what about the apparent pocketing of the communion wafer? Well, perhaps the prime minister accepted the wafer, as per his own Christian instincts, and suddenly realized that Catholics might be offended that he took it. So he made the snap decision not to ingest it, but to keep it pending consultation with someone else, perhaps the priest, as to what he should do with the consecrated host. Some time later, he somehow decided to eat it, and did, off camera.

It looks like there were mutual errors.  I believe the PMO would have briefed Harper, given former GGs don’t pass away that often, but the video appears to put him between a rock and a hard place. He had his hands folded, and perhaps no one told him to keep them folded to receive a blessing instead. I find it difficult to believe the priests would not have been briefed. It is a no win situation which didn’t need to happen. I am not defending Stephen Harper but I can’t defend the Archbishop and cathedral staff either. Stackhouse:

Alternatively, however, he might have done what is done in lots of Protestant churches, namely, hold on to the bread until everyone is served and then everyone partakes together in a ritual of solidarity–of communion. When he realized a few moments later, perhaps, that that ritual wasn’t going to take place, he might well have ingested it on his own, as the PMO says he did. Let’s be clear: Protestants rarely attend Catholic services, and vice versa, and there is enough variation in Christian services around to communion for people to be unsure of quite what to do in liturgies not their own.

Everyone, however, seems to have meant well. So it’s time to recall the advice of St. Peter, according to Catholic tradition the first pope: “Above all, love each other deeply, because love covers over a multitude of sins” (I Peter 4:8). And let’s move on to issues much more important to Canadian Catholics and Protestants alike.

About Bene Diction

Have courage for the great sorrows, And patience for the small ones. And when you have laboriously accomplished your tasks, go to sleep in peace. God is awake.
This entry was posted in General. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Damned if he does or doesn’t; Stephen Harper at Romeo LeBlanc’s funeral mass

  1. youthful says:

    When the late (Great) John Paul II was in Toronto 7 years ago for World Youth Day, there were a lot of non-Roman Catholics, including Ecumenical Visitors, and non-Christians, who took part in the Papal Mass, including some politicians….
    This is mere political mudslinging; I wonder how Ratzenberger (aka Pope Benedict) will receive Harper this weekend at the Vatican?

  2. Pingback: Playing Hide and Seek with the Body of Christ, and with YouTube videos | dv8-designs

  3. Bene D says:

    The ‘copy right claim’ by the CBC is a bit much given the footage is CPAC video and other copies remain online.


    a) thin skin
    b) getting leaned on

    The Roman Catholic Church, The PMO?

  4. Kate says:

    Even I, a heathen atheist, knows that if you are not catholic you are not even supposed to go up to receive the host, as you are not allowed, as a non-catholic, to receive the sacrament.

    As much as I am a part of the “It’s just a cracker” camp, it doesn’t mean that I would walk into the church of a faith that is not mine without first taking the time to LEARN A LITTLE ABOUT WHAT IS THE ACCEPTED AND POLITE THING TO DO!

    I mean, really…. USE GOOGLE, Mr. Prime Minister, and next time you won’t come off as an uneducated boob.

    Well, okay, you’ll still appear as an uneducated boob, but you’ll be far less likely to insult the very people you expect to vote for you.

  5. Pingback: Irving newspaper apologizes to reporters, Prime Minister at Bene Diction Blogs On

  6. Sean Bell says:

    The Priest who is running the Eucharist is actually able to include/exclude anyone that he wants.

    I was recently ordained as a Pastor in the ELCIC (Lutheran) and the local Roman Catholic and Anglican Priest attended the service and participated. There are the official rules that might make this sticky, and then there is reality and the ways that these things play out in small town Alberta.

    As one who offers communion, I would hope that all people felt welcomed to come forward as the table belongs not to any one person, but to all people. And the bread and wine is for all, not just people who qualify. (Having said this, I realize that some traditions think it ‘damaging’ to people who aren’t ‘prepared’ for the ‘free’ gift so be cautious approaching strange church tables).

    I think it’s awesome that Mr. Harper took the Eucharist – how are we going to get Catholics and Protestants and all others to live in peace if we can’t even eat together?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>