“We have the right to be stupid [about Todd Bentley]“

By Rick Hiebert All Rights Reserved. Used by Permission

Why does evangelist Todd Bentley, after the disgrace at Lakeland and being banned from entering Britain earlier this year, feel the need to keep going and going and going like the Energizer Bunny?

An e-mail of his from a few days ago shows that if God is trying to show Bentley that he needs to stop what he is doing through painful circumstance—in the same way that you learn not to hit your head with a hammer because it smarts a bit—He is not listening at all.

Todd Bentley seems to be incredibly stubborn. I’ll explain…

On November 30 [2012], Bentley sent out the e-mail Restoration Is Like A Two Edged Sword. Part of his e-mail reads like this:
…. But we need to remember that in the process of restoration there is always a divine test. Before Joseph’s freedom was restored, and he took the throne in Egypt (second only to Pharaoh), he was taken into a great God-ordained time of testing (Gen: 37-50). Psalms 105:19 says: “Until the time that his word came to pass, the word of the LORD tested him.” Joseph had the prophetic word of the Lord but until it actually came to pass, this word tested him.

Likewise, many of you have the prophetic word of the Lord concerning areas of restoration coming upon your lives; however, today, the fulfillment has not manifested it’s still on its way. Stand your ground in the time of testing, the time of waiting. God will surely come and bring restoration exactly at the perfect moment…..

Yes, Joseph was severely tested, and we may be tested as well. But the danger in looking at the Bible’s history is to assume that anything that happened back then should and will happen to us in the same way.

Joseph had a special role and destiny. How accurate would it be to assume that his example applies to everyone? Would it perhaps be hubris for Bentley to assume that Joseph’s example applies to himself?

Ah, but it has to apply. If it doesn’t apply yo Bentley he either goes back to be the low profile itinerant teacher that he was before Lakeland, or starts asking people if they want fries with their meal.

Bentley should, of course, be free to pursue whatever he wants to do. But if he is being pigheaded in wrongly continuing, there would be collateral damage. Bentley would not be the only person affected.

This brings to mind a couple items from earlier this year—when Bentley was banned from Britain’s immigration authorities from entering their country. Bentley’s latest musings are merely the latest example of his thinking “I *will* be a famous evangelist and no one will stand in my way of doing whatever I want to do when and where I care to do it.”

Back on September 21 [2012}, Bentley sent an e-mail to to his e-list. Intended to connect with Bentley’s supporters, it contains an interview with a lady who went to Lakeland and felt blessed by her experience there. (Her daughter, Sophia, after being “healed” of an incurable disease is now being “mentored” by Bentley and his second wife.).

Her question to Todd Bentley, and his response, is interesting:

… What was it inside of Todd that gave him the drive to overcome the adversity that he went though after Lakeland, because a lot of people would just have given up. There had to be something inside of him that gave him the courage to say, “I am not done” and stand up even after all the controversies. What was the one thing that really drew him to say, “I am not going to give up and I am not going to quit and I will continue to serve God”?

Todd’s Response: “A lot of people ask me this question. People always want to know how I kept myself strong, loving the Lord, and continued to pursue my purpose. During the first 6 months after Lakeland, which was a challenging time for me was a battle of depression and discouragement. I felt like Elijah the Prophet, I wanted to give up. It was the constant encouragement of Fathers and a few true friends that kept speaking life into me that kept me going. One blessing in this hardship that I endured, was that in the midst of it all, I fell back in love with Jesus for Jesus again and not for ministry.”…

Most people would be reluctantly willing to consider that God has another “purpose” in mind for them after the sorts of things that happened to Todd Bentley. Had Bentley been willing to pursue a regular job for a few years, we could place more credence in his saying that he loves Jesus before ministry.

No one else can possibly do what Todd Bentley does, I guess.

The fact that Todd Bentley is now mostly under the radar and not drawing huge crowds or the sort of attention that he did at Lakeland would imply that many christians are looking at Todd Bentley and saying “I’ll pass”.

But not all. And one response–which threw me for a bit of a loop—to Bentley being banned from entering Britain may show my Bentley will never deliver pizzas for a ,living, as long as he wants to keep evangelizing.

You have to credit blogger The Ugley Vicar for getting right to the nub of the matter. His August 23, 2012 post is entitled “We Have The Right To Be Stupid”.

Britain’s Home Office, as they write, has just decided that Bentley may not enter Britain for a series of evangelistic meetings.
This, the blogger decides, is a use of “dictatorial powers” :

“…And what, exactly, have we been saved from? The answer is a tattooed former drug addict who claims God heals via him giving them a punch or a kick.”

“Now I am quite happy to say this is bonkers (although I do remember reading about a bloke who was healed after somebody rubbed spit on his eyes – but then the government didn’t like that healer either, because he was a threat to the establishment too).

When it came to these shores, I similarly said the Toronto Blessing was bonkers, and I continue to maintain that to this day. (Indeed, I would go further and say it was spiritually damaging in a way far beyond anything likely to be achieved by Mr Bentley.)

But I also think the government is talking rubbish when it gives as a further justification for this ban, “Coming here is a privilege that we refuse to extend to those who might seek to undermine our society.”…

I follow the point they are making. The fact that, knowing all that I do about Bentley, I still watch what he is doing implies that I think that most Christians are grownups and can take care of themselves.

“We have a right to be stupid.” Indeed, you do.

I did ask myself, however, is this person being serious? Is this a “reducto ad absurdum” argument where they are going way over the top to really argue that the British government is really being reasonable?

(And would it be odd for a “Brit” to use a Canadian blogging server?)

But whatever the merits of what the blogger has to argue, they allow me to make a small point. Todd Bentley will always have someone willing to take his side and support him, no matter how unreasonable people, and the powers that may be, are.

With such a base of support, Todd Bentley will be able to keep evangelizing to the end of his days. He should be able to make a living of some sort.

This entry was posted in General. Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to “We have the right to be stupid [about Todd Bentley]“

  1. Susan says:

    Maybe he never stopped drinking from the Lord’s cup despite his way at Lakeland. In other words, “Quiet convictions often earn long-term respect”. Christians drink from the same cup. Yet we are asked to examine ourselves before partaking. Some of us may just like to drink from the cup anyway.

  2. Mark Byron says:

    We’re looking at a charismatic culture, especially post-Toronto, that is pro-weird and anti-intellectual; the latter has long-standing roots in evangelical circles, but the former is almost a hallmark of your NAR quadrant. “MMA moves to promote healing? Hey, Jesus healed with spit mud-pies, didn’t he?”

    Some folks in charismatic circles go looking for weird, and get it in spades with Bentley.

  3. hopesome says:

    The Divine calling that Mr Bentley ‘walks in’ seems to protect him from the reality of the everyday …….. oblivious to all but himself as the ‘Great I AM’ he meanders through the avenues of our desperation and hands out miracles to appease our needs of life ………. He appears completely sane within the insanity that is fast becoming our norm ………… delusion, deception and deb —– walk side by side him just daring us to openly challenge his ‘WAYs’ yet how can we when there just might be a chance that we get saved, prayed for, or miraculously healed!!! Thats the trap!

    The reality ………….. go way beyond him and find out who’s pulling his strings and why !!
    If he is challenging the real Jesus to come and confront him as he mocks his very core then he’ll be disappointed, for the Jesus I know will be quietly blocking his exits from his source of supply and demand and rendering his future pathways null and void …….

    the unseen is not so unseen any more !!

  4. hopesome says:

    Bentley was heading for the East End of London last time his ‘ways’ came to my attention ………. I wonder why !! The East End was notorious at one time for all sorts of ‘underhand activities’ ……… Some of us brits have ears to hear whats going on you know and have been known to take action accordingly !!!!!

  5. Susan says:

    There was a tradition about those mud pies. Everyman’s Talmud p.253, B.B. 126b. Jesus not only did a physical healing. He touched the spiritial eyes as well. Now that’s a healing!

  6. Brano says:

    demons & deception perhaps!

  7. hopesome says:

    What absolutely appalls me is this notion that he heals: He walks wrapped in self most of the time and only sees the potential to heal himself when he seeks the audiance of the desperate. Its false witness: Surely to god you want all to be partaking of this great cup of salvation and not just the chosen few: I would like the bank managers to have compassion for those they robbed, I would like the atmosphere in the towns and cities to compliment each other not vie with each others haves and have nots, I would like us all to come together and render each others deficits in the black and not constantly enjoy someone elses debts be they financial, physical, or spiritual but no Bentley has us begging for his magical remedy for salvation, a new i pad, wow I’m off to save africa, ye right! look at me people! Sorry but in my book we all deserve o be set free from lies and deceit and mockery not just those who pay lip service to the medicine mans needs of fame and fortune. Mr Bentley proove to me you can save us from the pit of greed, the threat of physical malfunction and ageism, poverty and penance and then maybe I’ll forgive you for leading us into your pathways and not his.

    PHEW feel better getting that of my chest: Thank you Mr Hiebert

  8. Brano says:

    Cheap,2 bit carnival show….Maybe Todd sees himself as the Ringmaster!?

  9. Kevin Kleint says:

    Needless to say, Todd Bentley has issues. I traveled with him to Uganda around 2003 and saw this nonsense firsthand.

    Not only that, I worked for the Elijah List for 7 years, so I am well acquainted with the mixture being peddled by the false prophets.

    If you want to read my account of what went on at the Elijah List and how it affected me you can go here: http://www.honorofkings.org/elijahlist

    ** Site mgr. – if it’s inappropriate for me to put my link on this comment, feel free to delete the last sentence.

  10. Pingback: Todd Bentley–MP died because he worked to have me banned from Britain | Bene Diction Blogs On

  11. Bonnie Emett says:

    I think all one has to do to figure out how and why Bentley and similar faux evangelists is to follow the money. That’s it……..$$$. Ignorant miracle seekers who have not one ounce of discernment continue to attend his medicine shows and buy the elixir…which is probably just alcohol in a bottle labeled, “Healing Water”. Just sayin’

  12. Brano says:


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>